My friend Umm A.R. alerted me to this story yesterday, and today The Jordan Times has more information
about the Indonesian domestic worker who was slain and whose body was dumped in a remote area. This story is yet another despicable tragedy in the annals of the relatively new history of domestic workers in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.
I have been suppressing the urge to write about my take on domestic workers in Jordan for some time. One of my dearest friends came to Jordan as a domestic worker (read: slave), and I have absolutely no tolerance when it comes to abuse of human beings in any capacity. One thing I try to do when discussing different cultures or races is avoid, like the plague, the two-cent stereotype. When speaking about domestic workers in Jordan and their widespread, well covered-up mistreatment, it is easy to fall into concluding
that those Arabs are cold-hearted and don't consider their maids as humans. Well, that is simply untrue. On the other hand, one might be able to toss up the blanket statements that
those Indonesians are too naive and will end up taking Egyptian boyfriends if you don't keep 'em on a leash, or
those Filipinas are too strong-willed and demanding and have to be shown their place. Stereotypes, as you know, all originate from some snippet of truth, but cannot be accepted as truths themselves. This is where our God-given abilities to observe, reason, and make conclusions based on our own observations should come into play. Gee, if everyone did this, I think we could eradicate racism in one fell swoop. I'm such an idealist.
So here's my story, and later we can discuss.
When we moved to Jordan I did not imagine that I would feel like a failure as a housewife. I now know why the woman who is only 45 years old looks more like 60. The physical demands on women here are difficult to articulate. You have to live it to know of what I speak. Dust is everywhere, and it creeps into homes with even the tightest of sealed windows. We even have metal window covers we pull down to cover the glass that is covering the screens that are behind 40 meters (ha!) of curtains to keep the dust out, but to no avail. Dust has a life of its own, is determined to rule, and rule it does. We have to dust every day, wash floors, wash all of our dishes by hand (dishwashers would consume too much water), clean bathrooms that mysteriously become flooded with water, sweep and sweep and sweep, and sweep some more. Plus most of us make our meals from scratch, and that includes sauces and everything. I do not know anyone who dumps jars of Ragu on pasta and says, "Dinner is served," because that
one jar would cost the same as it costs to make four batches of spaghetti with meat. No Lean Cuisine, no Marie Callender's, no quickie pop-in-microwave conveniences. They would break the bank.
What happens is that we adapt to the demands of cooking and cleaning in Jordan, and most of us, I must say, do an excellent job of it. Some of us even become obsessed with having to keep the perfect home, which is probably triple the work of doing so in the U.S. I fell into this mentality and so did many of my friends. The thought of in-laws popping in unexpectedly and the house being in shambles was enough to always keep me on my toes. In the process, however, I felt my lower back taking its revenge out on me. Oh, and then I had baby #4, who cried for months and months on end. I needed help: my husband saw it, my friends saw it, and I finally conceded. I thought that having a maid was going to be the lifesaver I needed.
Before I got my live-in helper, my dear friend whom I spoke of at the beginning came and lived with my family for three months. She cleaned my house and helped me with the kids; she was Filipina and had come here to work in a spa but the owners had been so vile that she had to run away. It is a long story but the important issue is that she had endured mistreatment and was happy to come and work for an American who smiled at her and who treated her as an equal. My experience with her in my house was exceptional. She just came over for dinner last night; she is a friend for life.
When I finally did get my permanent helper, I breathed a giant sigh of relief. I could leave my home without all four children in tow; I started working part-time doing what I love; after dinner I sat with my husband instead of washing dishes or cleaning up after the kids. I really turned my home over to this person, whose personality was quite strong. She claimed she had come from horrible working conditions and honestly when she arrived at my home she seemed awfully depressed. I was afraid to place many demands on her or to even show her how I wanted things done, because she droned on all the time about how 'bad she'd had it' elsewhere. Whatever she asked of me, I gave her. To make things more complicated, she had very close relatives living in a close proximity to me, and she had been promised by one of them that they could get together every weekend, all of this unbeknownst to me. Her entire premise of coming to work for me was that she was to have the role of nanny in my home, not housemaid. I did not need a nanny, but that is what I got.
She was not all bad. She had definite good qualities; she never stole from me, she was well-educated, and a really good cook. What bothered me the most was that
she wanted to run my house, and whenever I called her out on something, she became visibly irritated and snappy. I am not a fan of confrontation and for the first year I kept suppressing my feelings; I refused to be mean or to yell. After a year and a half, she asked if she could go to the Philippines to see her family. I really wanted to just release her from her contract, because at that point our communication had simply broken down. I hated having her in my home. My husband and I decided that letting her go would be a good thing, but after two weeks in the Philippines she kept messaging me that she was missing us and ready to come back to work. So she did.
The last six months of her contract were the worst. I really resented her and I made it known. I did not hold back on confronting her
when the situations merited it. I chastised her when she did things that I just simply, as the employer, did not like. I did not, however, mistreat her. She had always had free reign over the kitchen, eating and/or cooking as she wanted. I still let her visit her family members here. I always paid her on time, often gave her advances, and always mailed her letters to her family or wired money home when she asked me. But I really needed her out of my home and I needed her to stop interacting with my children. When it was time for her to leave, it was really time for her to leave.
I hope that she finds a good employer with whom she can see eye to eye and that whomever she works for knows what she is looking for in a job, because
housemaid was not it. I want to reiterate that she is not a bad person; she just was not the right helper for my family. But with all of the problems that we had, could I imagine, ever, tying her up with ropes? Putting her in a cold room and letting hypothermia set in? Hurting her or laying a hand on her,
in any capacity? A'oothu billahi min as-shaitan ir-rajeem. Do these people not fear Allah? How do people allow themselves to become so filled with hatred and indifference to the value of human life to do such acts? These are the things I cannot comprehend, and they happen every day here. Every day.
My family and I have been living helper-free since October. Yes, some days I want to just sit back and let someone come and do all of the work. But my older kids and I, as well as my husband, aka Mr. Vacuum, are handling it quite well I think.
Two days ago I took my three daughters to Carrefour; we had been down in the beled (city center) earlier and were running on little food for fuel, having had a minimalist's breakfast that morning. I told the girls we'd run upstairs in the mall and grab some sandwiches before we shopped. The sandwich joint where we ordered our food had four smiling Filipinas working behind the counter. I talked with them a bit while waiting on my order, then went to sit down and eat. With my first bite of sandwich, I glanced up to see three other Filipina housekeeping staff gathered around the food court garbage bin. They dug out two (or three, I couldn't tell) Happy Meals that people had thrown away, and began devouring the leftovers within. They called over one of the Egyptian workers to join them, and the four of them stood in plain sight, eating food from the garbage. I put my sandwich down, feeling ill. I nudged my oldest daughter to look over and witness this. She, too, put her sandwich down. The illness we felt was not from watching them eat out of the garbage, but from the sudden realization that
we were sitting in the midst of Gluttony; people all around us were devouring way too much food bought at way too high prices, and throwing it away. I told the girls to pack up their sandwiches and that we would finish them at home. Then I went back to the sandwich counter to interview the workers.
I learned that all four of them, when they leave work, sleep in the basement of a hospital, in the room adjacent to the morgue. I learned that their salaries are 140 JD /month ($200 US), but that they must buy all of their own food, which runs at least 60 to 70 JD/month. I learned that no one, since working in Amman since summer, has been able to send money home, which is the entire reason for their working here. And I learned that they are all thankful to God to have a job.
I will not soon forget their faces, nor will I forget the unnamed Indonesian girl whose life has been stolen.